Unlocking the Jersey Mike’s Secret Menu: A Guide to Hidden Sandwiches and Custom Creations
Jersey Mike’s Subs, renowned for its freshly sliced meats, quality ingredients, and the iconic “Mike’s Way,” is a beloved sandwich chain for a reason. But did you know there’s a whole other level of sandwich enjoyment waiting to be discovered? We’re talking about the legendary, albeit unofficial, Jersey Mike’s secret menu! This isn’t a printed list handed out at the counter; it’s a collection of customer-created combinations, insider tweaks, and resurrected classics known only to the savviest sandwich aficionados. This comprehensive guide will arm you with the knowledge to navigate this delicious world, order like a pro, and elevate your Jersey Mike’s experience to new heights.
## What is the Jersey Mike’s Secret Menu?
Think of the secret menu as a repository of culinary creativity fueled by hungry customers and inventive Jersey Mike’s employees. It’s a collection of sandwich combinations, ingredient swaps, and preparation styles that have gained popularity through word-of-mouth, online forums, and whispered recommendations. These aren’t officially sanctioned items, so you won’t find them on the menu board. You’ll need to know what you want and how to ask for it.
Why a secret menu? Well, it allows for customer customization and experimentation beyond the standard offerings. It’s also a fun way to engage with the brand and discover new flavor combinations that might not otherwise exist. Plus, who doesn’t love a little insider knowledge?
## Popular Secret Menu Items and How to Order Them
Here’s a breakdown of some of the most popular and talked-about secret menu items, along with detailed instructions on how to order them. Remember, clarity is key! Be specific with your requests to ensure you get exactly what you’re craving.
**1. The R.O.B. (Roast Beef, Onions, and Balsamic)**
This is a classic secret menu item favored for its simplicity and flavor profile. It’s all about highlighting the quality of Jersey Mike’s roast beef.
* **How to Order:** “Can I get a regular-sized roast beef sandwich, but can you add grilled onions and balsamic vinaigrette?”
* **Pro Tip:** Ask for it “Mike’s Way” to get the standard lettuce, tomato, and onions. You can also add your favorite cheese for an extra layer of flavor. Provolone pairs particularly well.
**2. The BLT (Beyond the Basics)**
While Jersey Mike’s officially offers a BLT, the secret menu version involves a few key upgrades to make it extra special.
* **How to Order:** “Can I get a BLT, but can you please add provolone cheese and make it Mike’s Way?”
* **Pro Tip:** For an extra kick, ask them to grill the bacon slightly longer for added crispiness. You can also add a touch of mayo or a drizzle of balsamic for a unique twist.
**3. The Big Kahuna Cheese Steak (Secret Upgrade)**
The Big Kahuna Cheese Steak is already a popular item, but you can take it to the next level with this secret menu modification.
* **How to Order:** “Can I get a Big Kahuna Cheese Steak, but can you add jalapenos and extra cheese?”
* **Pro Tip:** Specify the type of cheese you want for the extra cheese. Provolone is a classic choice, but pepper jack can add some heat. Also, if you’re a fan of spicy food, ask for extra jalapenos.
**4. The Chicken Philly (Secret Twist)**
A delicious alternative to the classic cheesesteak, the Chicken Philly offers a lighter yet equally satisfying option.
* **How to Order:** “Can I get a Chicken Philly, but can you add grilled onions, peppers, and mushrooms? Also, can you add provolone cheese?”
* **Pro Tip:** Ask for it with a little bit of white American cheese in addition to the provolone for extra creaminess.
**5. The Sub in a Tub (Keto-Friendly Option)**
For those following a low-carb or keto diet, the “Sub in a Tub” is a lifesaver. It’s essentially any sandwich made without the bread, served in a container.
* **How to Order:** “Can I get a [your desired sandwich] in a tub?”
* **Pro Tip:** Be specific about the ingredients you want. You can choose any of the regular sandwiches or create your own combination. Make sure to specify if you want it “Mike’s Way” or with any other special toppings.
**6. The Number 99 (The Rachel)**
This is a variation of the popular Reuben, using turkey instead of corned beef. It used to be on the regular menu but has since been relegated to secret status.
* **How to Order:** “Can I get a Number 99, the Rachel? It’s the turkey Reuben with coleslaw and Russian dressing.”
* **Pro Tip:** If the employee isn’t familiar with “The Rachel,” simply describe the ingredients: turkey, coleslaw, Swiss cheese, and Russian dressing on toasted bread.
**7. The Surf and Turf (Premium Indulgence)**
This secret menu item is a combination of roast beef and tuna salad. It might sound unusual, but some swear by this flavor combination.
* **How to Order:** “Can I get a sandwich with both roast beef and tuna salad on it?”
* **Pro Tip:** Ask for your preferred cheese and toppings to customize the flavor profile. A little bit of lettuce and tomato can add some freshness to balance the richness of the tuna and roast beef.
**8. The Tomato Basil Wrap (Vegetarian Delight)**
This is not necessarily a secret menu item, but it is a great option for vegetarians. The wrap provides a lighter alternative to bread and highlights fresh flavors.
* **How to Order:** “Can I get a tomato basil wrap with provolone cheese, lettuce, tomato, onion, and a drizzle of balsamic vinaigrette?”
* **Pro Tip:** Ask them to add some roasted red peppers or artichoke hearts for extra flavor and texture.
**9. The Philly Special (Cheesesteak Customization)**
The Philly Special is a customizable cheesesteak experience. The beauty of it is that you can request any topping you desire on the cheesesteak.
* **How to Order:** “Can I get a Philly Cheesesteak with [list the toppings you want]?”
* **Pro Tip:** Some popular topping suggestions include hot peppers, sweet peppers, mushrooms, extra cheese, bacon, and different types of onions such as fried or grilled.
**10. The Pepperoni & Cheese (Simple Satisfaction)**
Sometimes the simplest combinations are the best. If you’re in the mood for a quick, cheesy, and pepperoni-packed delight, order this secret sandwich.
* **How to Order:** “Can I get a Pepperoni and Cheese sandwich with provolone, lettuce, tomatoes, and onions?”
* **Pro Tip:** Get it Mike’s way to ensure the classic flavors combine perfectly.
## Tips for Ordering from the Secret Menu
Ordering from a secret menu can sometimes feel intimidating, but with a little preparation and a friendly approach, you can navigate it with ease. Here are some tips to ensure a smooth and successful ordering experience:
* **Be Prepared:** Research the secret menu items beforehand and know exactly what you want to order. This will save you time and prevent confusion at the counter.
* **Be Specific:** When ordering, clearly and concisely explain what you want. Use the exact names and descriptions provided in this guide. The more specific you are, the better chance you have of getting your order right.
* **Be Polite:** Remember, the employees may not be familiar with every single secret menu item. Be patient and courteous, and explain what you’re looking for in a friendly manner.
* **Be Patient:** Since secret menu items are often custom-made, they may take a little longer to prepare. Be understanding and allow the employees ample time to create your masterpiece.
* **Be Open to Suggestions:** If an employee is unsure about a particular secret menu item, be open to their suggestions or alternative ways to achieve a similar flavor profile.
* **Don’t Be Afraid to Experiment:** The secret menu is all about customization and creativity. Don’t be afraid to try new combinations and create your own unique sandwich masterpiece.
* **Ask About Ingredients:** If you have any allergies or dietary restrictions, be sure to ask about the ingredients in the secret menu items. It’s always better to be safe than sorry.
* **Know Your Mike’s Way:** Understanding the standard “Mike’s Way” toppings (lettuce, tomato, onions, oil, vinegar, and spices) is crucial for customizing your sandwich. Always specify whether you want your secret menu creation “Mike’s Way” or with any modifications.
* **Consider the Location:** Some Jersey Mike’s locations might be more familiar with certain secret menu items than others. If you’re unsure, try ordering a simpler combination first.
* **Use Online Resources:** Many online forums and websites dedicated to Jersey Mike’s offer a wealth of information about secret menu items and customer creations. Take advantage of these resources to discover new ideas and get inspiration.
## Creating Your Own Secret Menu Item
The real beauty of the secret menu is the ability to create your own custom sandwich. Here’s how to unleash your inner sandwich artist:
1. **Start with a Base:** Choose your favorite bread and protein. Jersey Mike’s offers a variety of breads, including white, wheat, and rosemary parmesan. As for proteins, the options are endless, from roast beef and turkey to ham and tuna salad.
2. **Add Cheese:** Select your preferred cheese. Provolone, Swiss, American, and pepper jack are just a few of the choices available.
3. **Pile on the Toppings:** Get creative with your toppings. Lettuce, tomato, onions, pickles, peppers, mushrooms, and jalapenos are all great additions.
4. **Choose Your Sauce:** Select your favorite sauce to add flavor and moisture. Options include mayonnaise, mustard, oil, vinegar, and various dressings.
5. **Experiment with Combinations:** Don’t be afraid to try new and unusual combinations. The possibilities are endless!
6. **Name Your Creation:** Give your custom sandwich a catchy name. This will make it easier to order in the future and share with friends.
7. **Share Your Creation:** Spread the word about your secret menu masterpiece. Share your creation on social media or with other Jersey Mike’s enthusiasts.
## Beyond Sandwiches: Secret Menu Potential in Other Areas
While the secret menu is primarily focused on sandwiches, you can also apply the principles of customization to other items on the Jersey Mike’s menu.
* **Salads:** Create your own custom salad by combining your favorite ingredients from the sandwich station. You can even ask for your sandwich filling to be served as a salad.
* **Wraps:** Experiment with different wrap combinations by swapping out the bread for a tomato basil wrap.
* **Drinks:** While less common, you can try creating custom drink combinations by mixing different sodas or adding flavor shots.
## Why the Secret Menu Matters
The Jersey Mike’s secret menu is more than just a collection of hidden sandwiches; it’s a testament to the power of customer creativity and the brand’s commitment to customization. It allows customers to explore new flavor combinations, personalize their dining experience, and feel like they’re part of an exclusive club.
By embracing the secret menu, Jersey Mike’s fosters a sense of community and encourages customers to engage with the brand in a meaningful way. It’s a win-win situation for both the company and its loyal patrons.
## Conclusion: Unlock Your Jersey Mike’s Potential
The Jersey Mike’s secret menu is a treasure trove of delicious possibilities waiting to be discovered. By following this guide and embracing your inner sandwich artist, you can unlock a whole new level of enjoyment at your favorite sub shop. So, the next time you’re craving a Jersey Mike’s sub, don’t be afraid to venture off the beaten path and explore the hidden delights of the secret menu. You might just discover your new favorite sandwich!
Now that you are equipped with the knowledge to explore and enjoy the Jersey Mike’s secret menu, go forth and create! Remember to be specific with your requests, polite to the staff, and above all, have fun experimenting with the flavors and combinations available. Happy sub-hunting!